Tnrtv: Reviews I Wish I Hadn't Written...

I'm guessing it's his notorious positive review of Yes Giorgio!

Sigh.  Nope, he thinks he underrated Godard.  Now I remember why I stopped reading his reviews a long time ago.

Goddard is overated, Stanley.

What is Kauffmann suggesting here?

This: That when we react to something not able to be accessed [and then assessed] objectively we can only take out of it what we first put into it. This: All of the accummulated experiences and relationships we have had that nudged [or yanked] us in one direction rather than another.

This is true for both aesthetic and ethical [political] assessments. If, for example, someone just viewed the film, "4 Months, 3 Weeks and 2 days", and another asks, "is this a great film?" or "does the film demonstrate abortion is immoral?", we will get answers to both questions all along the value judgment continnum.

Not only this but our answers are always subject to change as we accummulate new experiences and new relationships.  In other words, everything is always in flux here. There is no objective manner in which to judge the aesthetic worth of flim, art, music etc.; anymore than there is an objective standard from which we can derive universal orders of morality.

Note for example how J Dyer pulverizes any possible ambiguity about the worth of Godard's films above. He assures us that Godard IS overated. As though something like this can be known....can be known epistemologically?

On one level, sure, most of us will readily agree things like this are just a matter of opinion. But on another level lots of folks out there can't bring themselves to admit this is an inherent aspect of human relationships. Value judgments are no less equivocal than the moral and political contexts out of which they are derived.

george walton

d/a

In this TNRtv exclusive, Bruce Riedel contends that the "Taliban are winning" the war in Afghanistan