The Plank . The Treatment

Max Baucus, Genius?

I've been pretty hard on Max Baucus for a while, especially as he spent months and months negotiating fruitlessly while Democratic political capital rotted away. But it's worth pointing out that his plan, assuming he had one, worked perfectly. Three months ago, the main storyline in the press on health care centered on whether Democrats would craft a bipartisan bill (yay!) or go it alone (boo!) Through his painstaking, and often pathetic, desire to reach an agreement with the GOP, Baucus proved beyond a doubt that serious GOP support for any remotely comprehensive health care reform was totally impossible. Indeed, the "go it alone" theme was all but disappeared from the press coverage. Meanwhile, the right-wing grassroots anti-reform insanity has largely burned itself out, and the popularity of President Obama and his health care reform has bounced back.

I still think he's more Mr. Magoo than Machiavelli, but fair is fair. Credit to Baucus.

COMMENTS (1)

10/14/2009 - 5:13pm EDT | iambiguous

No, the main "storyline" in the press was about sideshows like "Democratic political capital" dwindling away on healthcare reform while the gun-toting, rowdy truthers at the townhalls revealed just how vulgarian BeckWorld conservatives and the insurance corportions could be.

Max Baucus?

He IS the system in Washington:

Lawyers/Law Firms $1,603,523

Securities & Investment $1,478,035

Insurance $1,196,463

Health Professionals $1,039,276

Pharmaceuticals/Health Products $756,205

Come on Jon, "proving" the Republicans were never serious about "real" healthcare reform. That's your lead here? That's the Baucus angle?!!!

Again, here's my angle:

The Washington-Wall Street production ... view full comment

Reinhold Niebuhr at TNR

The Alternatives to Communism

Is exporting democracy the way to stop totalitarian dictators?

Liberalism: Illusions and Realities

Does Kirk's "Conservative Mind" make any sense?

The Puritan Conscience

The flawed origins of U.S. exceptionalism.

Our Stake in the State of Israel

Will we abandon our one secure bastion in the Middle East?

Liberals and the Marxist Heresy

Grappling with the fellow travelers--and McCarthy.

Vietnam: Study in Ironies

Why America is losing its way in Southeast Asia.

get the magazine

Intellectual rigor. Honest reporting. Influential analysis. Don't miss another issue of the magazine considered "required reading" by the world's top decision-makers. Subscribe today.

Get our newsletters

Get Our Feed