Life Just Got a Lot Harder for Arkansas Inmates

The most obvious tragedy of the Washington police shootings is the deaths of the four police officers. The fact that the suspected gunman is a convicted felon from Arkansas whose 95-year prison sentence was commuted by then-Governor Mike Huckabee in 2000 is a tragedy for anyone currently in prison in Arkansas who might hope to one day receive executive clemency. Just consider what happened in Massachusetts after Willie Horton.

As Michael Blanding wrote in the Boston Globe Magazine a few months back:

In Massachusetts, however, there hasn’t been a single commutation approved by a governor since 1997 -- and there were only seven in the previous 10 years (four for murderers). Over the past 22 years, more than 650 petitions have been denied. In that same period, Delaware has approved hundreds, 12 for convicted murderers. Michigan’s Democratic governor has approved 23 in the past five years; in the prior 12 years, her Republican predecessor approved 34. And from 2003 to 2007, Maryland’s Republican governor granted 15 commutations, including five for life sentences for murder.

It’s no secret why Massachusetts has lagged behind: the memory of Willie Horton, the convicted murderer who terrorized a couple, raping the woman, in 1987 after escaping while on a weekend furlough allowed by then governor Michael Dukakis. The act pretty much torpedoed Dukakis’s presidential campaign a year later when ads showing Horton’s picture and images of inmates going through a revolving door hit the airwaves. Even years later, it lays bare the thorny political calculus of letting a felon out of jail. There is almost nothing for a governor to gain and everything for him to lose should the criminal commit another crime. “Ever since what Willie Horton did to Mike Dukakis, governors are going to think not twice but 10 times before they ever commute anyone,” says retired judge Robert Barton, who presided over the Donovan case. Tufts University political science professor Jeffrey Berry agrees. “If I was a governor’s adviser,” he says, “I would recommend he be very cautious.”

Just last week, Arkansas Governor Mike Beebe granted 10 pardons. If Massachusetts is any guide, it might be a while until he grants another one.

COMMENTS (8)

11/30/2009 - 1:50pm EDT |

It looks like Mike Huckabee's chances of ever being elected President just vaporized.

11/30/2009 - 2:59pm EDT |

desert, yeah I thought the same thing, but 2012 is a long way away, and the fact that he is a minister does give him something of an out. And the strangest thing is he was right to do what he did (how could he possibly know what would happen) he commuted a 95 year sentence meted out to a 17 year old.

11/30/2009 - 2:59pm EDT |

desert, yeah I thought the same thing, but 2012 is a long way away, and the fact that he is a minister does give him something of an out. And the strangest thing is he was right to do what he did (how could he possibly know what would happen) he commuted a 95 year sentence meted out to a 17 year old.

11/30/2009 - 3:22pm EDT |

No good deed goes unpunished, blackie. The Republican party has taken this maxim to heart and resolved to never again commit any good deeds.

Also, since comments are closed on the post about the TNR poll, I'll bitch about it here: seriously folks, if you're asking people to rate statements on a scale from true to false, you can't make each choice exclusive to one statement. I'm sure this is covered in week three of Elementary Internet Poll Design 101.

11/30/2009 - 3:25pm EDT |

The only factor that argues against desertdog's thesis is the fundamental hypocrisy of the political right. A movement where Sara Palin is seen as an exemplar of "family values" might not hold the assassinations of four cops by a commuted felon against Mike Huckabee. That, and only that, keeps even a flicker of hope for a Huckabee presidential nomination alive today. Huckster is very lucky to be a Republican -- though unlucky in that he would have to run against other Republicans to get the GOP nomination, and they will attempt to go Horton on the Huck.

11/30/2009 - 5:19pm EDT |

What rattie said about the poll design.

Speaking of the poll, it's nice that the winner gets a pile of books and 5 free subscriptions. Does this mean the runner-up gets three piles of books and 20 free subscriptions?

[rimshot!]

[loud, sustained applause!]

Oh, thank you, thankyouverymuch, yertookind. I'm here 'til Hanukkah--try the pork!

[standing ovation!]

Oh, such a nice crowd...

11/30/2009 - 8:10pm EDT |

Well I'm gonna be here for the rest of my life.
And all I did was shoot my wife.

11/30/2009 - 8:13pm EDT |

Nice Johnny Cash ref, CRS.

get the magazine

Intellectual rigor. Honest reporting. Influential analysis. Don't miss another issue of the magazine considered "required reading" by the world's top decision-makers. Subscribe today.

Get our newsletters

Get Our Feed