You are using an outdated browser.
Please upgrade your browser
and improve your visit to our site.
Skip Navigation

Robert Frank, Liberal Icon

In my review about the resurgence of Ayn Rand-ism on the right, I cited an op-ed by Cornell economist Robert Frank. I called Frank's central point, that luck plays a huge role in success, "seemingly banal." It occurs to me -- I haven't heard from Frank or anybody about this point -- that that line sounded dismissive. I didn't intend it that way at all. Sometimes very bvious points nonetheless go unmentioned in a public debate, and Frank usefully brought that one to the surface.

I also referred briefly to his subsequent appearance on Fox to defend his op-ed. The appearance is really remarkable, and I don't think I managed to do it justice. The way Frank calmly made his points in the face of a tirade by a blustering, self-satisfied, demagogic host was a tribute to both the power of reason and its generalized absence on cable television in general and Fox in particular. If I knew a young, apolitical intellectual, and wanted to convince him or her to identify as a liberal rather than a conservative, I would probably show this segment: